It’s no secret: there are a lot of digital and social media agencies out there. (Some estimates even put the number as high as 87,000.) And whether the agency is large or small, national or local, nearly all of them will likely tell you that they can help your brand grow.
Choosing a social media agency isn’t just about finding someone that can create content or manage your channels. It’s about finding a true partner that understands your organization, knows how to connect strategy to results, and can help you use digital/social media in a more intentional and effective way.
If you’re currently in the process of evaluating social media agencies, here are three important things to consider before making your decision:
1. Strategy Should Come Before Content
In the fast-moving world of social media, there’s no doubt that content matters — but strategy has to come first.
If an agency jumps straight into talking about how often they’ll post, what kinds of videos they’ll create, or which trends they want to try, that should give you pause. Those tactics may all have value, but without a clear strategy behind them, it’s easy to end up with content that looks busy but doesn’t actually move your organization forward.
A strong social media agency partner will start by understanding your audiences, your goals, and how digital and social media fit into your broader communications or marketing efforts. From there, they should be able to build a plan that connects content to something bigger — whether that is driving awareness, generating leads, increasing attendance, supporting fundraising, or strengthening your brand.
Simply put: if there’s no strategy, there’s a good chance you’ll just be posting for the sake of posting.
2. They Should Be Able to Connect Their Work to Real Results
It’s easy for an agency to point to a polished feed, a trending video, or a post with a lot of likes to make it seem like they are a good fit for your brand. However, it’s important to look closer and get the story behind these vanity metrics to know whether their work is actually making an impact.
This doesn’t mean that every conversation with a potential agency partner has to be filled with spreadsheets and analytics. It does mean an agency should be able to clearly explain what success looks like, how they measure it, and how their work supports your larger organizational goals.
For example, if your goal is event attendance, are they focused on getting the right people to take action? If your goal is thought leadership, do they understand how content can build credibility over time? If your goal is sales, are they thinking beyond engagement and implementing a strategy that emphasizes conversions?
The right agency won’t just make sure your social media channels are active. They’ll help you understand whether your digital and social media efforts are actually effective.
@scootermediaco We work in socialmedia, of course we’re going to hop on this trend! #ScooterMedia #Trend #ofcourse #AgencyLife #SocialMediaManagers
3. They Should Feel Like a True Agency Partner, Not a Vendor
When you’re choosing a social media agency, you’re trusting an outside team to help represent your brand. That takes more than just the technical skills of drafting content and getting it posted to various platforms; it takes communication, collaboration, and a genuine understanding of how your organization operates.
A good agency partner will be responsive, transparent, and clear about expectations. They should be able to explain their thinking, not just present deliverables. They should also be willing to ask smart questions and offer recommendations based on experience — even when that means pushing back on an idea that may not be the right fit for your brand’s social channels.
The best agency relationships feel like a partnership, not a transaction. You should come away feeling like the agency is invested in your success, not just checking items off a scope of work.
Final Thoughts on Choosing a Social Media Agency
Choosing a social media agency is a big decision, and finding one that is the right fit can make an incredible difference in how your brand shows up online.
As you evaluate your options, look beyond the sales pitch. Focus on whether the agency leads with strategy, understands how to measure meaningful results, and feels like the kind of partner you and your team can truly work with.
At Scooter Media, we help organizations build digital and social media strategies that are intentional, effective, and grounded in driving real results. Whether you need support with content strategy, day-to-day social media management, training, or a broader digital communications partner, our team is here to help.
Get in touch with us today to learn how Scooter Media can help your organization strengthen its digital and social media efforts.
Check out these other blog posts from the social media experts at Scooter Media:
