Hiring a public relations agency is one of the most crucial decisions a company can make, particularly if you are aiming to increase awareness, build your reputation, or enhance your community impact. As someone who has spent more than two decades in the agency world (including the last 14 years leading Scooter Media), I’ve seen firsthand what makes a PR partnership thrive, and what can cause it to fall short.
The right PR agency should do more than check boxes or complete tasks; it should help you connect the dots between your company’s business goals and communication efforts. At Scooter Media, we approach every client relationship as if we are part of their internal team. We join your marketing team meetings, ask questions, and take the time to understand your industry, your challenges, and your priorities. We’re not just focused on the deliverables; we’re invested in your success.
Here are three key considerations to help you find the right PR agency partner.
#1: Transparency Matters
One of the most important qualities in a PR agency is clear and transparent communication. You want a team that’s responsive, collaborative, and honest, especially when expectations need to be managed or adjusted.
As you evaluate agencies, prioritize those that lead with strategy and measure success in more than just impressions. Success could be reflected in a positive shift in public perception, improved community engagement, new donor sign-ups, or an increase in qualified leads driven by earned media.
Ask potential agency partners about their approach to planning, reporting processes, how they define success, and how they align communications with your business objectives. For example, at Scooter Media, we use quarterly strategy reviews and monthly reporting to ensure we’re on track and moving the needle in the right direction for your organization.
#2: Let’s Talk About Budgets
Don’t be afraid to talk about the budget early in the process. A great agency will be upfront about costs, tailoring services to your priorities, and helping you avoid scope creep by clearly defining deliverables and expectations.
Likewise, being transparent with your budget allows your agency partner to recommend the most effective strategies within those parameters. When an agency understands what resources are available, it can provide smarter, more realistic guidance and often uncover creative ways to maximize impact. If an agency can’t provide clarity around pricing or contract terms, it’s a red flag.
#3: Telling It Like It Is
Be cautious of agencies that guarantee media coverage, overpromise, or that can’t clearly explain how they work. A trustworthy PR partner will be honest about their strengths and transparent about what falls outside of their expertise. They won’t take on work just to secure your budget, only to outsource it behind the scenes.
Instead, the right agency will help you assemble the right team. This may mean collaborating with another agency or referring you to a trusted freelance partner. Look for teams that are upfront about their capabilities, propose realistic KPIs, and have a track record of success in similar industries and verticals.
Finally, ask for references. Speaking with current or former clients gives you valuable insights into an agency’s work style, process, and results.
Ultimately, the right PR agency should feel like an extension of your internal team. Finding an agency that is aligned with your mission, responsive to your needs, and invested in your success is vital. They’re honest when things shift, creative when budgets are tight, and always focused on the big picture. That’s what we strive for at Scooter Media.
Looking for the right PR agency partner in the Cincinnati/Northern Kentucky region? I’d love to connect. Learn about who we are and the services we offer here. Or email me directly at shannan@scootermediaco.com – I’d be happy to talk with you.
Want to see what we’ve been up to? Explore our work, discover insights into our thinking, and see how we deliver exceptional client service by following us on Facebook, LinkedIn, Instagram, X, TikTok, and Bluesky.
